In United States v. Langston, the Second Circuit vacated and remanded a violation of supervised release. The government conceded that the judgment should be vacated, because the District Court had held a hearing on the violation over the objection of Langston and his counsel, who was not prepared, but disagreed that the case needed to be reassigned to … Read more
Yesterday, in a published opinion, the Second Circuit reversed the convictions in an off-label drug importing case because the district court erroneously excluded evidence concerning the advice of counsel defense. The opinion in United States v. Scully, No. 16-3073 (Pooler, Lynch, Cogan (by designation) (appeal from Spatt, J., EDNY) is available here. The opinion touches … Read more
Today the Second Circuit vacated a criminal forfeiture order so that the district court could evaluate the defendant’s ability to pay in setting the amount. The summary order in United States v. Muzaffar, 16-579 (appeal from EDNY, Cogan, J.) is available here. The Supreme Court, in United States v. Bajakaijan, 524 U.S. 321 (1998), identified four … Read more
This article by the Marshall Project looks at recent efforts to limit in-court identifications. Led by the work of the Innocence Project, efforts to reduce wrongful convictions caused by in-court identifications are making progress. Connecticut, for example, has prohibited in-court identifications unless the witness knew the defendant prior to witnessing the events at issue or … Read more
The New York City Bar Association will be hosting a panel on “How to Become a State or Federal Defender” on Monday, April 17, 6pm – 8pm. Register here. Description: This panel will discuss the qualifications for and application process to become a public criminal State or Federal Defender in New York. Panelists will consist … Read more
Attorney General Jeff Sessions issued another memo to US Attorneys this week. You can access the memo here. In it, he establishes a “Task Force on Crime Reduction and Public Safety” to identify ways federal prosecutors “can more effectively combat illegal immigration and violent crime, such as gun crime, drug trafficking, and gang violence.” The … Read more
David Patton, the Executive Director and Attorney-in-Chief at the Federal Defenders of New York, published an opinion piece in yesterday’s New York Daily News. Patton points out that while much of the press following Bharara’s firing focused on his reputation as the “sheriff of Wall Street” or the drainer of the Albany swamp, these high-profile cases do … Read more
Earlier this month, the Department of Justice issued new guidelines for the use of photo array identification procedures. You may find this useful in support your request for an expert in cases in which these procedures were not followed. The ABA Journal has an update on the policy as well as links to the DOJ … Read more
In an opinion written by Judge Newman, the Second Circuit today vacated the defendants’ sentences of 30 and 21 months, respectively, for food stamp fraud for the district court to consider imposing non-guideline sentences on the ground that the defendants’ Guidelines ranges were significantly increased by the loss enhancements, an unusual feature of the Guideline … Read more
Defense attorneys in Chicago have moved to dismiss cases on the basis that the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives (the ATF) violated the equal protection clause by targeting people of color for its fake stash house sting cases. The Federal Defenders, CJA Panel attorneys, and the Federal Criminal Justice Clinic at the University … Read more